Why Was the Book of Jasher Removed from The Bible?

The Book of Jasher, also known as the “Book of the Upright” or “Sefer HaYashar” in Hebrew, is a mysterious text referred to in the Old Testament. Despite its mentions in Joshua 10:13 and 2 Samuel 1:18 as a source of historical information, it is absent from the conventional biblical canon. Why was it removed? The exclusion of the Book of Jasher can be attributed to historical, theological, and authorship-related factors.

1. Lack of Standardization

The Book of Jasher faced challenges in terms of standardization. Unlike many books that made it into the Bible, there was no universally accepted version of the Book of Jasher. The absence of a consistent and agreed-upon text contributed to its exclusion from the biblical canon.

2. Authorship Uncertainty

A significant hurdle for the Book of Jasher was the uncertainty surrounding its authorship. The lack of a clear attribution to a known figure of authority raised doubts about its authenticity. The process of canonization favored texts with a recognized and reliable authorship, and the Book of Jasher did not meet these criteria.

3. Theological Scrutiny

Theological considerations played a pivotal role in the selection of books for the biblical canon. The Book of Jasher, despite containing historical and narrative content, faced theological scrutiny. The absence of a clear alignment with prevailing theological doctrines made it a subject of skepticism among religious authorities.

4. Canonical Decision-Making

The process of determining the canonical books of the Bible involved careful consideration by religious authorities of the time. Factors such as widespread acceptance, usage in liturgy, and theological coherence influenced the inclusion or exclusion of texts. Unfortunately, the Book of Jasher did not secure a place in this esteemed collection.

5. Historical Skepticism

The historical reliability of the Book of Jasher became a point of contention. Scholars and religious leaders of antiquity questioned the accuracy of its historical accounts. This skepticism, coupled with the absence of a standardized text, contributed to the book’s omission from the final compilation of the biblical canon.

6. Theological Misalignment

Beyond scrutiny, the Book of Jasher faced challenges related to its alignment with established theological doctrines. The absence of a clear theological fit with the prevailing beliefs of the time may have played a role in its exclusion from the biblical canon.

7. Lack of Ritual Use

Canonical decisions often considered the practical use of texts in religious rituals. Since the Book of Jasher did not have a recognized role in liturgical practices, it lacked a crucial element that contributed to the inclusion of other texts in the Bible.

8. Limited Geographic Acceptance

The acceptance of biblical texts varied across different regions. The Book of Jasher may not have gained widespread approval in certain geographic areas, further limiting its chances of inclusion in the biblical canon.

9. Historical Context

The period in which the decisions about the biblical canon were made also played a role. Historical circumstances, such as political and cultural factors, could have influenced the exclusion of the Book of Jasher.

10. Theological Evolution

Theological beliefs evolved over time, and texts that did not align with the evolving theological perspectives faced challenges. The Book of Jasher, having been circulated during a time of theological flux, might not have seamlessly integrated with the emerging theological frameworks.

Who Discovered the Book of Jasher?

The history of the Book of Jasher’s discovery is intriguing, involving both ancient and modern instances.

Ancient Discovery

The Book of Jasher is mentioned in the Bible itself, in Joshua 10:13 and 2 Samuel 1:18. However, the book referred to in these verses is likely a different work or a collection of songs and poems rather than the Book of Jasher as we understand it today.

READ:  Lost Gospels of the Bible PDF

Rediscovery in the 18th Century

The rediscovery of the Book of Jasher is a relatively recent phenomenon, and credit for this goes to Jacob Ilive, an 18th-century English scholar. In 1751, Ilive claimed to have found the Book of Jasher in a Hebrew manuscript during his travels. While some scholars questioned the authenticity of Ilive’s find, his discovery marked a pivotal moment in the text’s journey from obscurity.

Circumstances of Discovery

Jacob Ilive published what he claimed to be the Book of Jasher in 1751. Derived from a Hebrew manuscript, his edition stirred debates on authenticity. Some scholars questioned the legitimacy of the manuscript, adding an air of uncertainty to the rediscovery.

Legacy of the Rediscovery

Despite skepticism, Jacob Ilive’s discovery brought the Book of Jasher back into scholarly discussions and public awareness. While debates continue over its authenticity, Ilive’s find serves as a crucial moment in the text’s journey from obscurity to renewed interest.

Impact on Scholarship

Jacob Ilive’s rediscovery had a significant impact on biblical scholarship, sparking renewed interest in previously overlooked texts. The Book of Jasher, once relegated to obscurity, became a subject of scholarly exploration and debate.

Influence on Later Discoveries

The rediscovery of the Book of Jasher paved the way for later explorations into forgotten or obscure biblical texts. Scholars, inspired by Ilive’s work, began to delve deeper into ancient manuscripts in search of hidden treasures.

Cultural and Historical Reverberations

Beyond the academic realm, the rediscovery of the Book of Jasher had cultural and historical reverberations. It prompted a reconsideration of historical narratives and contributed to a broader understanding of the rich tapestry of ancient texts.

Challenges to Rediscovery

Despite its newfound attention, challenges persisted regarding the Book of Jasher’s authenticity. The ongoing debates and uncertainties added layers of complexity to its status in the realm of biblical studies.

Do Jews Believe in The Book of Jasher?

Examining the importance of the Book of Jasher in Judaism involves acknowledging its historical standing and its place in the Jewish community.

Historical Standing

While not considered a primary scripture, some Jewish scholars recognize the historical value of the Book of Jasher. It is regarded as a supplement rather than a core religious text, providing additional insights into biblical stories and historical events.

Diversity of Beliefs

Judaism encompasses a diversity of beliefs, and attitudes toward the Book of Jasher reflect this diversity. Some within the Jewish community find merit in the book for its historical narratives, while others approach it cautiously due to the lack of consensus on its authenticity.

Cultural Importance

The Book of Jasher is acknowledged for its cultural importance within Judaism. While not held in the same esteem as canonical texts, it contributes to the broader cultural and historical context of Jewish tradition.

Educational Use

In educational settings, the Book of Jasher is occasionally employed as a supplementary teaching tool. It offers alternative perspectives and additional details, enriching the understanding of biblical narratives and contributing to a more comprehensive grasp of Jewish history.

Cautionary Approach

However, it is important to note that the Book of Jasher is approached with caution within the Jewish community. The absence of a universally accepted version and uncertainty about its authorship contribute to a more reserved stance compared to canonical texts.

READ:  How Many Books in The Bible About Women?

Role in Rituals

The Book of Jasher lacks a defined role in Jewish rituals, further impacting its acceptance. Canonical texts often play a crucial role in religious ceremonies, and the absence of the Book of Jasher from these practices contributes to its cautious treatment.

Influence on Jewish Thought

Despite its cautious reception, the Book of Jasher has left an imprint on Jewish thought. Its narratives and perspectives, when considered, have contributed to nuanced discussions within the community.

Contemporary Perspectives

Modern Jewish perspectives on the Book of Jasher vary. Some view it as a valuable historical resource, while others maintain a more skeptical stance. The evolving nature of these perspectives reflects the ongoing dialogue within the Jewish community.

Where Can One Find the Book of Jasher?

If you’re curious about where to find the Book of Jasher, here’s a simple guide.


Unlike the main books, you won’t find the Book of Jasher in typical bookstores. However, it is available on online platforms, including Amazon. Websites focusing on ancient texts or religious studies often feature it. Additionally, some libraries, especially those with extensive religious or historical collections, may have a copy.

Search Considerations

It’s essential to note that the Book of Jasher may not be as widely available as popular books, requiring a bit of searching. While it might not be as famous as the main Jewish texts, checking online retailers like Amazon can be a good starting point in your quest for a copy.

Specialized Bookstores

Exploring specialized bookstores that focus on religious texts and ancient manuscripts might increase your chances of finding the Book of Jasher. These stores often cater to a niche audience interested in less mainstream but historically significant works.

Digital Libraries

In the digital age, many libraries offer digital collections. Searching online repositories or digital libraries specializing in religious texts might provide access to the Book of Jasher or scholarly discussions surrounding it.

Consultation with Scholars

Engaging with scholars in the field of religious studies or biblical history could offer valuable insights. Scholars may guide you to reputable sources, share their perspectives on the Book of Jasher, or recommend specific editions for study.

Exploring Ancient Manuscripts

Given the Book of Jasher’s ancient origins, exploring collections of ancient manuscripts in reputable institutions may yield valuable results. Institutions with a focus on preserving historical texts could house editions or references to the Book of Jasher.

Academic Conferences and Publications

Academic conferences and publications in the field of religious studies often discuss lesser-known texts. Exploring these avenues may lead to information on the Book of Jasher, including where to find scholarly editions or analyses.

Collaborating with Religious Institutions

Establishing contact with religious institutions or organizations that specialize in biblical studies may provide guidance on accessing the Book of Jasher. These institutions may have resources or recommendations based on their expertise.

Online Forums and Communities

Joining online forums or communities dedicated to religious studies could connect you with individuals who share similar interests. Members of these communities may offer suggestions on reputable sources for accessing the Book of Jasher.

FAQs About Why the Book of Jasher Was Removed from The Bible

1. Which Bible contains Jasher?

  • The Book of Jasher is not included in any modern Bible canon. It is mentioned twice in the Hebrew Bible, in Joshua 10:13 and 2 Samuel 1:18-27. However, the original Book of Jasher has been lost, and there is no consensus among scholars on what it originally contained.
READ:  How Many Languages Has the Bible Been Translated?

2. What happened to the original book of Jasher?

  • The original Book of Jasher is believed to have been lost sometime before the 1st century AD. There are several theories about what happened to it, but there is no definitive answer. Some scholars believe that it was destroyed in the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 AD, while others believe that it was simply lost over time.

3. Is the Book of Jasher in the 1611 Bible?

  • No, the Book of Jasher is not included in the 1611 King James Bible. The King James Bible only includes the books that were considered to be canonical by the Church of England at the time. The Book of Jasher was not considered to be canonical, so it was not included in the King James Bible.

4. Is Jasher a book of the Apocrypha?

No, the Book of Jasher is not a book of the Apocrypha. The Apocrypha is a collection of books that were not considered to be canonical by the Hebrew Bible. The Book of Jasher is mentioned in the Hebrew Bible, so it is not considered to be part of the Apocrypha.

5. Who was the king of Africa in the book of Jasher?

There is no mention of a king of Africa in the Book of Jasher. This may be a reference to a later work that is falsely attributed to the Book of Jasher.

6. What books were removed from the Bible?

There are several books that were once considered to be canonical by the Jewish people but are not included in the modern Bible canon. These books are called the deuterocanonical books or the Apocrypha. The deuterocaonical books are:

  • Tobit
  • Judith
  • Esther (Greek version)
  • Wisdom of Solomon
  • Sirach
  • Baruch
  • Letter of Jeremiah
  • Song of the Three Young Men
  • Daniel (Greek version)
  • Maccabees 1
  • Maccabees 2

The deuterocaonical books were not included in the Hebrew Bible that was compiled by the rabbis at the Council of Jamnia in the early 2nd century AD. The rabbis decided that only the books that were written in Hebrew or Aramaic and that were written before the time of Alexander the Great should be included in the canon. The deuterocaonical books were written in Greek and were written after the time of Alexander the Great, so they were not included in the canon.


Exploring the mysteries of the Book of Jasher led us through historical challenges, from the absence of standardization to scrutiny on a religious level. Jacob Ilive’s rediscovery in the 18th century thrust the text into the limelight, sparking debates and shaping subsequent scholarship. A closer look at its place in Judaism reveals a nuanced perspective, recognizing its historical value while approaching it with caution.

For those on the hunt for the Book of Jasher, the digital era provides various avenues for exploration, ranging from online platforms to digital libraries. Connecting with scholars and religious institutions can offer valuable guidance, enhancing our grasp of this captivating biblical text.

Even though the Book of Jasher is not part of the modern biblical canon, its historical significance, cultural importance, and influence on scholarly discussions endure. This invites ongoing exploration and discussion, adding depth to the broader realm of biblical studies.

Leave a Comment